The Arctic This Week Take Five: Week of 16 December, 2024

Back to Publications

Mysterious Explosions Near Russia’s Key Arctic Naval Base 

The Barents Observer reported on December 19 that several large explosions occurred near Severomorsk, the headquarters of Russia’s Northern Fleet. Local residents documented two major blasts at 17:24 and 17:27 local time, which shook buildings across Murmansk, 13 kilometers away. Norway’s NORSAR research foundation detected corresponding infrasound signals from the Kola Peninsula minutes later. The explosions took place close to several military installations including the Severomorsk-1 naval air base, weapons depots, and air defense sites. No statement has been issued by Russian authorities as of yet regarding the cause. (The Barents Observer)

Take 1: The Severomorsk explosions expose vulnerabilities in what was once seen as Russia’s most secure military stronghold. The significance extends beyond the immediate incident – Severomorsk is Russia’s primary Arctic naval base, home to its Northern Fleet and the command center for its nuclear-capable vessels. The proximity of the blasts to such critical military infrastructure raises fundamental questions about the security of Arctic military assets previously considered safely isolated by geography and climate. While the cause remains unconfirmed, the incident forces a broader reassessment of Arctic military security assumptions. The lack of official Russian communication about such a significant event near major military installations and population centers suggests possible gaps in Arctic defense capabilities. As regional military activities intensify, this event may prompt Arctic states to reevaluate their high north military infrastructure protection strategies. (CSIS, Reuters, The Barents Observer)

Novatek Executive’s Washington Mission Reveals Arctic LNG Crisis 

High North News reported on December 12 that a senior Novatek executive traveled to Washington, DC, for discussions about U.S. sanctions on Russian Arctic LNG projects. U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Geoffrey Pyatt confirmed the visit, stating that sanctions relief would not be considered while Russia’s war continues. The company faces expanding restrictions on its Arctic LNG 2 project, Belokamenka construction yard, Chinese suppliers, and specialized LNG carrier fleet. The company is reported to have spent $300,000 on lobbying efforts in Washington during 2023. (High North News)

Take 2: This diplomatic effort reflects the Arctic’s shift from a zone of economic cooperation to an arena of geopolitical competition. Once a model of international collaboration, Novatek’s LNG projects now illustrate how Arctic energy has become entangled with global security concerns. The timing is notable – coming after Western technology partners withdrew and sanctions expanded to Asian suppliers, the Washington visit underscores the severe impact of these restrictions on Russia’s Arctic ambitions. Beeyond the immediate commercial implications, this development marks a shift in how Arctic resources are viewed in international relations. European nations that once considered Russian Arctic LNG essential to energy security now prioritize reducing Russian influence, even at economic cost. The U.S. rejection of sanctions relief, despite potential effects on the global LNG market, suggests this securitization of Arctic energy will extend beyond current tensions. These changing dynamics have significant implications for future Arctic development, as projects once evaluated primarily on commercial merit become inseparable from broader geopolitical calculations. (High North News)

European Critical Minerals Strategy Gains Arctic Foothold 

Norge Mining announced on December 16 its acquisition of Skaland Graphite AS, Europe’s largest natural graphite producer, through Norwegian subsidiary Norge Mineraler Holding AS. The Skaland operation, located on the Arctic island of Senja 200 kilometers north of Tromsø, produces 10,500 tonnes of graphite annually and ranks among the world’s top producers outside China. The deal, valued at an undisclosed amount, comes months after China implemented new graphite export controls and the EU reclassified graphite as a Strategic Raw Material. Norge Mining expects to close the acquisition in Q1 2025. (Arctic Today)

Take 3: This acquisition represents an important step in Europe’s efforts to achieve strategic autonomy in critical minerals. With China controlling 74% of global graphite anode production and implementing tighter export restrictions, Skaland’s role as Europe’s sole major graphite producer holds strategic value despite its relatively modest output. The timing of the deal, following China’s export controls and the EU’s designation of graphite as a Strategic Raw Material, reflects a broader shift in how Arctic resources are integrated into global supply chains. Beyond traditional Arctic extractive industries like oil and gas, the transaction highlights the region’s emerging role in securing materials essential for green technology. For Norway, the deal represents more than industrial growth; it positions the country as a significant contributor to Europe’s critical mineral strategy. As nations race to secure supplies for the energy transition, this acquisition underscores the increasing importance of northern resources in global industrial competition and green technology development. The deal suggests future Arctic resource development may increasingly focus on critical minerals rather than fossil fuels. (Arctic Today, Benchmark Source)

Arctic Shipping Routes Face Unexpected Challenges 

University of Ottawa scientists reported at the Arctic Change conference on December 11 that shipping seasons in Canada’s Northwest Passage are shrinking despite declining ice coverage. Lead researcher Jackie Dawson explained that, between 2007 and 2021, mobile multi-year ice has created hazardous ‘choke points,’ reducing northern route accessibility from 25 to 15 weeks annually in some areas. Research presented by WWF-Canada from the National Vessel Dumping Assessment also found that, despite lower shipping activity compared to southern regions, Arctic marine protected areas receive a disproportionate share of vessel waste, with 28% of grey water being discharged in protected zones. (Nunatsiaq News)

Take 4: These findings challenge assumptions about Arctic shipping’s future, showing that climate change brings complexity rather than simply improving accessibility. The unexpected shortening of shipping seasons, despite reduced overall ice coverage, highlights gaps in our understanding of Arctic maritime dynamics. This paradox holds particular significance for global trade, as nations like Russia have invested heavily in Arctic routes as alternatives to traditional corridors. The research demonstrates how unpredictable ice movements create new hazards, complicating route planning and safety measures even as traditional barriers diminish. The environmental implications are equally notable – concentrated shipping activity during shortened seasons increases pressure on sensitive Arctic ecosystems and marine protected areas. This suggests a need to fundamentally rethink Arctic shipping strategies, balancing economic opportunities with improved safety measures and environmental protections. Success in Arctic maritime operations will depend on better ice forecasting, stricter environmental standards, and greater integration of Indigenous knowledge in route planning. (Nunatsiaq News, World Wildlife Fund)

Chinese Rig Makes Significant Oil Discovery in Norwegian Arctic 

The Barents Observer reported on December 16 that the Norwegian Offshore Directorate has confirmed a new oil discovery near the Goliat field in the Barents Sea, containing between 1.6 and 8.3 million standard cubic meters (10-52 million barrels). The discovery was made by the COSL Prospector, a rig owned by Chinese state company COSL Drilling Europe. Vår Energi, which operates the field with a 65% stake alongside Equinor‘s 35%, plans to drill three additional wells in the area during 2025 to assess further potential resources. (The Barents Observer)

Take 5: This discovery marks more than just another Arctic oil find; it reflects China’s growing involvement in Arctic governance through strategic commercial presence. While China identifies as a “near-Arctic state,” its influence in the region has traditionally been limited by geography. However, by securing roles in resource extraction through state-owned enterprises, China can gain practical leverage in Arctic decision-making that bypasses traditional governance structures. This development is particularly notable as it takes place in Norway, a key Arctic Council member. The acceptance of Chinese state-owned companies in sensitive Arctic operations, despite security concerns, suggests how commercial engagement can contribute to broader regional influence. This approach raises important questions about Arctic sovereignty and whether existing governance frameworks can effectively address the growing influence of non-Arctic states operating through commercial proxies. (GIS Reports, Konrad Adenauer Foundation, The Barents Observer)