Urgent Call to Reform Outdated Sexual Violence Laws in Latin America and the Caribbean

Outdated sexual violence laws in Latin America and the Caribbean are failing survivors. A new guide urges consent-based reforms to strengthen legal protections.

BOGOTA, COLOMBIA, April 11, 2025 /EINPresswire.com/ -- Across Latin America and the Caribbean, sexual violence remains one of the most pervasive forms of gender inequality, with outdated and sex-discriminatory legal frameworks failing to provide effective protection for victims. A new guide by Equality Now and ParlAmericas provides a comprehensive framework for legislating on sexual violence to help ensure national laws align with international human rights standards.

LEGAL GAPS AND OUTDATED RAPE LAWS LEAVE SURVIVORS UNPROTECTED

Research by Equality Now found that 23 of the 43 national and subnational jurisdictions surveyed in Latin America and the Caribbean define rape based on the use of force, threats, or the victim’s physical inability to resist rather than the absence of voluntary and free consent. These outdated definitions fail to reflect the realities of sexual violence, particularly in cases where power imbalances, coercion, or vulnerability prevent victims from physically resisting or saying no.

Produced by legal experts, ‘The Guide to Legislating on Sexual Violence’ underscores the urgent need to shift away from legal definitions of sexual violence that require proof that force was used, as this can perpetuate harmful myths and stereotypes and limit the scope for accountability for rape.
The embeddedness of these myths and stereotypes within many regional legal frameworks and judicial practices perpetuates the normalization of sexual violence and shifts blame onto survivors instead of establishing the culpability of perpetrators. As a result, survivors frequently face legal obstacles that discourage reporting, create ambiguity in court proceedings, and contribute to low conviction rates—ultimately undermining trust in justice systems.
To address these issues, laws and policies should instead adopt a consent-based approach that strengthens protections for survivors, improves access to justice, and holds perpetrators accountable.

THE NEED FOR CONSENT-BASED LEGAL DEFINITIONS

International human rights standards require that legal definitions of rape and other forms of sexual violence be based on the lack of voluntary and free consent. Discriminatory definitions of sexual violence, when not premised on a strong understanding of consent, can discourage survivors from reporting and create a lack of clarity for court proceedings.

Force-based legal definitions of rape perpetuate the myth that it is the responsibility of victims to protect themselves and fail to take into account how victims may remain passive or freeze. Nor do they generally recognize the broad range of coercive situations where rape can happen without the use of physical violence or force, such as when the perpetrator exploits unequal power dynamics, trust, influence, and/or the victim’s dependence on them.
Survivors may delay reporting sexual violence due to social stigma, fear of retaliation, or lack of family support. It can be difficult to provide physical or medical evidence at a later date to prove additional violence was involved. Such a burden of proof on the survivor hinders the legal process by making it harder to prosecute cases.

RECOMMENDATIONS TO REFORM SEXUAL VIOLENCE LAWS

To increase access to justice for survivors in Latin America and the Caribbean, it is crucial to close all legal gaps relating to consent in sexual violence laws. The guide provides legislative recommendations that call for adding the lack of consent as the central element of rape and crimes of sexual violence. This covers all forms of unwanted penetration of a sexual nature, regardless of the object or body part used.

The publication outlines how penal codes must comprehensively recognize the contexts and coercive circumstances where consent can neither be freely given nor inferred. Legal frameworks must address sexual violence in situations involving power imbalances and within families, eliminating any provisions that exempt rape committed within marriage or intimate relationships.

The guide also calls for the abolition of discriminatory legal provisions such as estupro, which applies when the alleged perpetrator is an adult and the victim is above the legal age of consent but under 18. This provision carries significantly lower penalties than those established for rape, creating a discriminatory gap in the protection of adolescent girls.

Beyond criminalization, legislative reforms must be survivor-centered and developed in consultation with survivors and civil society organizations. A participatory approach strengthens legal frameworks, ensuring they are responsive to the lived realities of survivors and provide the necessary mechanisms for them to seek justice and other support if desired.

By adopting a consent-based approach, parliamentarians have the opportunity to dismantle outdated legal definitions rooted in force, eliminate myths and stereotypes that hinder justice, and align national laws with international human rights obligations. The guide equips lawmakers with the tools to build a more just and equitable legal system that upholds survivors’ rights and hold perpetrators of sexual violence accountable.

****************************************************************************

About Equality Now: Founded in 1992, Equality Now is an international human rights organization dedicated to protecting and promoting the rights of all women and girls worldwide. Its work is organized around four main program areas: Achieving Legal Equality, Ending Sexual Violence, Ending Harmful Practices, and Ending Sexual Exploitation, with a cross-cutting focus on addressing the unique challenges faced by adolescent girls.
Equality Now combines grassroots activism with legal advocacy at the international, regional, and national levels to achieve systemic change, and collaborates with local partners to ensure governments enact and enforce laws and policies that uphold women’s and girls’ rights.

For more details go to www.equalitynow.org

About ParlAmericas: ParlAmericas is the institution that promotes parliamentary diplomacy in the inter-American system. Composed of the 35 national legislatures of North, Central, and South America, and the Caribbean, it promotes cooperative political dialogue, facilitates the exchange of good legislative practices, and develops resources to support the work of parliamentarians.
ParlAmericas works towards democratic strengthening and the promotion and protection of human rights, addressing hemispheric priorities. It promotes gender equality in the parliamentary sphere, advocating for the application of a gender perspective and an intersectional approach in parliamentary work. Led by and for parliamentarians, ParlAmericas is governed by a Board of Directors of parliamentarians who serve as executive members and sub-regional representatives and are appointed by member parliaments. The International Secretariat of ParlAmericas is based in Ottawa, Canada.

For more details go to www.ParlAmericas.org

Tamara Rusansky
Equality Now
+55 21 99966-3828
email us here
Visit us on social media:
Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Instagram
YouTube